Facts matter. Stories move people. When a prospect hears how someone like them solved a similar problem, belief shows up and next steps feel safe. This guide shows how to find proof, shape it, and use it in calls, emails, websites, and COI intros without hype.
1) What a proof story is
A short client win told in plain words. No jargon. No numbers you cannot support. It answers three things: who it was for, what they were stuck on, and what changed.
Shape it
- Who: a simple label clients see themselves in
- Stuck: one sentence on the pain or risk
- Move: the small action you guided
- Change: the result in human terms and a light metric if allowed
You could say
“A couple in Franklin was worried about a premium surprise at sixty five. We staged income at sixty three and sixty four. Their premiums stayed in the lower bracket and they felt in control of the plan.”
2) Where to find proof
You create wins every week. Capture them before they fade.
Sources
- Meeting notes where a client said this helped
- Thank you emails or comments that describe the benefit
- Plan updates where a rule changed and stress dropped
- COI feedback after a shared case
Quick capture rule
Every Friday, write one new story in two sentences. Keep a simple log you can search.
3) Keep it accurate and compliant
Use generic labels, not names. Skip performance claims. Stick to facts you can document. If your firm requires approval, keep a folder of ready stories with the date you submitted and the date approved.
Safe framing
- “This helped them feel” not “This guarantees”
- “Tended to lower taxes over time” not “Cut taxes in half”
- “One page summary and a cash map” not “Custom algorithm”
4) Story templates you can copy
Call line
“Families I help often want a cash floor and no surprises at sixty five. Last month we set a refill rhythm and staged income at sixty three and sixty four for a couple in your spot. Would a one page note on that be useful?”
Email block
Subject: That cash and Medicare question
“A couple in Franklin felt uneasy about cash and future premiums. We set a true cash floor and timed income before sixty five. If you want the one page outline, reply send. If a quick call is better, I can do Wednesday at two or Thursday at ten.”
Website blurb
“Dual earners in their fifties came in unsure about retirement taxes. We built a twelve month cash map and scheduled income to avoid premium surprises. They left with a simple rule and a date to review it.”
COI intro line
“I work with dual earners who want steady income and simple taxes. Recent win a client avoided a premium surprise by timing income before sixty five. If that comes up with your clients, I have a one page you can forward.”
5) Use proof across the funnel
- First calls: one story to earn a tiny next step
- Follow ups: add a proof line that matches their worry
- Website: sprinkle three short wins on the page
- COIs: send one relevant story they can pass along
6) Make stories easy to recall
Most advisors forget good lines in the moment. Keep a living evidence log with tags like cash, Medicare, rollover, business owner, widow, concentrated stock. Review it before call blocks.
Log fields
Date, client label, problem, move, change, exact words they used, where you have permission to use it
7) Measure the effect
Track where you used a story and what happened. Over a month you will see which ones open doors and which ones fall flat.
Simple scoreboard
Story used, channel, response yes or no, meeting booked yes or no, notes for next time
Tiny case sketches
Case 1: Quiet website lift
Maya added three short proof stories to her home page and service page. Each was two sentences with a simple label and a change. Form fills doubled the next month and calls were easier to start.
Case 2: Better follow ups
Anthony added one proof line to each follow up email. Replies rose and several people asked for the one page mentioned in the story. His second meetings picked up.
What to document this week
- Three proof stories you can tell in two sentences
- One call line and one email block you will use
- Tags for your evidence log and where it lives
- A plan to add two stories to your website
- A note to one COI with a forwardable story
.png){kind=small}
